Opinion: Grumbling aside, Starbucks changes positive for customers (25 Feb 2016, The Wise Marketer)
The Wise Marketer - Home Subscribe to our RSS feed!   Share it!   
Email this page to a friend! Tweet this! Share this via LinkedIn! Share this on Facebook! Share this on Google Plus!
  Mobile Edition Tablet Edition
   The Wise Marketer          Customer Strategy Network             Log In          Register for Free   
  
Stay up to date with What's Hot in the world of Customer Loyalty and Marketing All the latest Customer Loyalty and Marketing News and Developments worldwide - just the facts Facts, Figures and Stats to support your Loyalty, Engagement and Marketing initiatives Opinion and Analysis from the world's most respected Customer Loyalty and Marketing luminaries
The Loyalty Guide - the only complete global Guide to Customer Loyalty, Engagement and Marketing Feature Articles and How-To Guides by the world's most respected Customer Loyalty and Marketing experts Details of the top Customer Loyalty and Marketing Conferences worldwide Search The Wise Marketer from top to bottom!
   The Wise Marketer   

Get your headlines by email every Thursday - Free!

Opinion: Grumbling aside, Starbucks changes positive for customers

   
Swap to the printable version of this page
Print!
 

Thursday February 25, 2016                      Tweet this article

 


Welcome to the big time, Starbucks. The US-based coffee chain, which this past week announced major changes to its loyalty programme, has now joined the rarified ranks of the airlines, hotels, and other retailers that have come before them: operating a loyalty programme so successful that their customers have come to view it as an entitlement. Making any changes to such a successful and entrenched programme is always difficult—never more so than when members can immediately crash Twitter with their collective complaints about the changes. If Starbucks can weather the storm, however, then the evolution of Starbucks Rewards will position the programme to evolve into an even more valuable one for both the retailer and its 11 million active members.

In essence, Starbucks is following in the footsteps of the major airlines and the recent evolution of their frequent-flyer programmes: the retailer is changing its reward programme from a mileage-based (or in this case, a frequency-based) programme to one based on customer spend. Instead of earning one “star” for each transaction, members will now earn two stars per dollar spent. From the company’s perspective, the move solves two problems: it speeds up the checkout process, as members will no longer ask cashiers to ring up one item at a time to accumulate more transactions; and it reduces programme cost in the form of fewer transaction fees.

As for customers, the changes are, as they always are, a mixed blessing: members who typically only stop in for a cup of coffee will now wait longer for their free cup, while members who buy food products, multiple drinks, or otherwise rack up big tickets will earn as fast or faster. In addition, the retailer is adding new ways to earn stars—at the grocery store and at the company’s Teavana stores—and is eliminating the programme’s Welcome level, which means that all members now earn Green-level soft benefits.

Those members who stand to lose most, of course, grumbled the loudest, with social media exploding and mainstream news outlets reporting on customer dissatisfaction. The changes also prompted a few competitive pot-shots, with Dunkin Donuts offering Starbucks customers a free cup of coffee for joining its Perks programme.

Does the media backlash mean that Starbucks erred in changing its programme? Far from it. Making any substantial changes to a large, established programme is a lot like ending the programme altogether, and successful execution means following a carefully-crafted exit strategy.

In this case, Starbucks exhibited many exit-strategy best practices: the retailer explained the changes clearly; it didn’t apologize; it over-communicated the changes; and it gave members ample time to adjust to them. The only trick the retailer arguably missed is the opportunity to practice targeted generosity by allowing members to “round up” to a reward before the changes go into effect—but with 11 million members, such a move might be cost-prohibitive.

Far from damaging the brand, in fact, Starbucks’ move has positioned the programme for continued long-term success. Rewards will now go primarily to the retailer’s most valuable customers. Adding bonus days allows Starbucks to motivate customers along temporal and store variables, which will add to programme ROI. Starbucks executives continue to cite the programme as a key factor in their earnings. And pilot tests with such earn partners as Spotify and Lyft reveal that the retailer has designs to expand Starbucks Rewards into a true multi-merchant partner programme.

All of these changes ultimately mean more benefits for Starbucks’ most valuable customers, and bigger returns for Starbucks’ shareholders. That’s the definition of a symbiotic value exchange. If, in the short term, the retailer loses a few low-spending customers to Dunkin Donuts—well, sometimes that’s the price we pay for greatness.

-Rick Ferguson


More Info: 

http://www.starbucks.com

> The Customer Loyalty Marketing Guide

Tell a friend about this article Tell a friend   or   Tweet this article

Have your loyalty news delivered - free.

Get all the most important customer loyalty and marketing news by email every Thursday, and it's still absolutely Free ...
Sign up!

 

What is The Wise Marketer?

We're the only truly unbiased, global source of news & research for customer loyalty and marketing professionals...   Join Free Here

See The Loyalty Guide 7 up close, and find out how to increase profits and market share with more effective loyalty marketing!

Join nearly 13,000 other loyalty and marketing professionals and get our free weekly news roundups...

Sign Up For Free

Subscribe and follow...

Get our free weekly newsletter
Follow us on Twitter
Access our RSS news feed

Hot off the presses...

What's been happening recently?

Insight: Marriott surprises with early loyalty linkage - Marriott Rewards and Starwood Preferred Guests (SPG) members woke up Monday morning this week to find that, contrary to conventional wisdom and Marriott's own public statements, the ...
Survey: Mobile loyalty members prefer SMS - A new survey from 3CInteractive reveals that removing friction from mobile loyalty applications will become a top 2017 priority for marketers. Loyalty programme takeup likewise stands at the top of ...
Research: Investing in customer retention leads to increased market share - From the research wire: A new study from Forbes and Sailthru gleaned from 300 global CEOs, media, and retail executives reveals that those brands that upped their ...
Special offer: Join our FREE Loyalty Academy beta test on September 27! - The Wise Marketer Group is pleased to announce the beta launch of the Loyalty Academy, the first-ever online certification programme for loyalty marketers. As you are ...
Insight: Is Apple Pay a threat to brand loyalty? - Mobile Commerce Daily has a column from Bond Brand Loyalty EVP Sean Claessen that raises some compelling questions about the role third-party mobile wallets such as Apple Pay will play in ...
US: Office Depot rewards students for putting down the device - We all know how distracting our devices can be to our personal and professional lives. Head-down screen time interferes with our social interactions, our home lives, our ...
Insight: Data-rich retailers lack customer identity capabilities - UK's Retail Times reports on a new study by technology consultant Amido that reveals a core retail challenge: retailers are awash in customer data but still struggle to ...
Canada: American Express Canada launches pay-with-points option - Transacting in Canada just got a little more fungible: American Express Canada last week announced the launch of UsePoints for Purchases, a new capability that allows eligible ...
US: Marriott highlights Rewards members in new campaign - Here's a novel idea: A major hospitality brand actually giving life to the idea of customer loyalty by showing what actual loyalty programme members look like. That's the tact taken ...
UK: British Airways to end Diamond Club in November - It's the end of an era for UK frequent-flyers: British Airways has announced that effective November 30, it will shutter the venerable Diamond Club loyalty programme. At that point ...
Survey: loyalty programmes influence retail holiday sales - eMarketer reports that ecommerce is poised to upend holiday shopping this year: while overall retail holiday sales are poised to grow by an anemic 1.8%, ecommerce retail holiday ...
News: AAdvantage members still fuming about programme changes - We're on record here as supporters of the Big Three U.S. airlines migrating their loyalty programmes from mileage-based to revenue-based earning structures. Grumbling and ...
Insight: How returns data can fuel customer relationships - Here at the Wise Marketer, our mantra is that a successful marketing strategy places all marketing in service of building sustainable, long-term customer relationships. Doing so ...
Insight: Measuring incrementality key to loyalty marketing success - One of the common critiques of loyalty marketing as a customer strategy is that programmes merely "subsidize" behavior, rewarding loyal customers for shopping habits they ...
Special offer: Join our FREE Loyalty Academy beta test on September 13! - The Wise Marketer Group is pleased to announce the beta launch of the Loyalty Academy, the first-ever online certification programme for loyalty marketers. As you are ...
US: Whole Foods to roll out loyalty programme nationally - The latest evidence that Wall Street analysts continue to consider customer loyalty a sound business investment: Over at Fox Business, Motley Fool commentator Bradley Seth McNew ...
Survey: Both digital and print coupon use on the rise - A new research study from Valassis Research reveals that, while consumers continue to use digital coupons in increasing numbers, print coupons are far from dead, with one-third of ...
Insight: Banks slowly adopting mobile loyalty - American Banker reports that consumer banks, while late to the game, have come to realise that they will need to join retailers and travel providers in digitizing their loyalty programmes and ...
Report: Cyber-attacks damage retail customer loyalty - Consumers are wary of the increased frequency of cyber-attacks against retailers, and many are ready to walk away from their favorite retailers if a breach occurs. In fact, according to ...
News: Uber and Visa partner on local rewards - As reported in TechCrunch, Uber and Visa have partnered on a reward programme that will reward Uber riders with free rides for patronizing local businesses. To make the programme a frictionless ...

  ... Never miss anything important - join nearly 13,000 marketing professionals and get our free weekly newsletter, written by marketers for marketers - sign up here!

 

See The Loyalty Guide 7 up close, and find out how to increase profits and market share with more effective loyalty marketing!
  
                          
   The Wise Marketer   
   Published By & Copyright 2016 Customer Strategy Network / The Wise Marketer. All rights reserved.   
The Wise Marketer - Home Subscribe to our RSS feed! Share this on Facebook! Share this on Google Plus! Tweet this! Share this via LinkedIn! Email this page to a friend!